How to write a performance improvement plan for an employee
A performance improvement plan (PIP) is a short written plan that tells an employee exactly where their work falls short, what good looks like, what support you will give, and by when you will review it. Write it only after you have already given clear feedback, keep it to two or three pages, use measurable targets, agree it with HR first, and treat it as a real chance to improve, not as paperwork before a dismissal.
Free · one email
Today's script for the talk you're putting off.
The words to open, the pause and the next step, from a 10-minute lesson. Day 1 is free; plans are $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year after.
Get today's script freeThis guide is for managers who have been told, or have decided, that an employee needs a formal plan. Below: whether you need one at all, what to do first, what the plan contains, a filled-in example, the words for the meeting, how to run the check-ins, how it ends, and the mistakes that cause trouble. It is general guidance, not legal advice; your HR team or an employment lawyer decides what applies where you work.
What a PIP is, and what it is for
A performance improvement plan for employee problems that can be fixed is a support tool first and a paper trail second.
A performance improvement plan is a written, time-limited agreement about what must change in someone's work. Its purpose is to make expectations impossible to misunderstand and to give the person real support to meet them. Done well, many employees do recover. Done badly, it is a paper trail that everybody, including the employee, reads as the first step to leaving.
That second reading is common, so be honest about it. If you have already decided to let someone go and nothing they could do would change your mind, a PIP is not fair to them. Talk to HR about the exit instead; our guide on how to fire an employee nicely covers that conversation. Use a PIP only when you would be glad if it worked.
Check these before you write anything
Most PIPs fail because they are the first time the employee hears how serious it is. Before you start, answer these:
- Did you tell them clearly and early? At least one direct conversation, ideally two, where you said what was wrong, gave examples and asked for a change. If not, start there: see how to give difficult feedback.
- Did they know the standard? A written role description, target or example of good work. If you never set it, set expectations first.
- Is it a skills problem, a will problem, or something else? Training gaps, unclear priorities, a broken process, a health issue, a family crisis or a conflict with a colleague all need different responses.
- Could the cause be something you must handle differently? If illness, disability, pregnancy, a leave of absence or a complaint is involved, stop and speak to HR before anything is written. Rules differ by country and state, and mistakes here are costly.
- Have you compared how you treat others? If a colleague with the same gap gets less scrutiny, fix that first.
- Is HR on board? Many companies have a standard form, a required approval and a fixed length. Use theirs.
Do not skip this list: a plan built on a gap the employee was never told about is the one most likely to go wrong. Our guide on how to manage an underperforming employee covers the steps that come before a PIP.
Dreading the conversation? Get today's script free, then see which hard talks your style tends to put off and get a ready script a day.
What goes in a performance improvement plan for an employee
Keep it short: two or three pages. Longer plans bury the point. Use these seven parts.
| Part | What to write |
|---|---|
| 1. Basics | Employee, role, manager, start date, review dates, end date |
| 2. The gap | Two to four specific areas where work falls short, each with dated examples and the standard expected |
| 3. The goals | For each gap, what "meeting the standard" looks like, in a number or an observable behaviour |
| 4. The support | What you will provide: training, a mentor, a clearer process, time, a weekly meeting |
| 5. The timeline | Total length and check-in dates, commonly 30, 60 or 90 days depending on the role and your company's policy |
| 6. The consequences | One plain sentence on what happens if the goals are not met, as approved by HR |
| 7. Signatures | Employee and manager, and a line saying signing means "received", not "agreed" |
How to write goals that can be measured
The goal section decides whether the plan is fair. Vague goals ("improve attitude", "be more proactive") cannot be met or failed, and they are the usual reason a PIP is challenged. Turn each concern into something a third person could check.
| Vague | Measurable |
|---|---|
| Be more reliable | Start work by 9:00 and tell me before 9:00 if you will be late; no unexplained absences in the 60 days |
| Improve quality | Fewer than 2 errors per 50 reports in a manager's spot check, down from 7 per 50 in the last two months |
| Communicate better | Send the weekly status update every Friday by noon, using the team template; reply to team messages within one working day |
| Better attitude | Describe the behaviour: "interrupting colleagues in meetings; speaking dismissively of others' work". Goal: no interruptions reported in the weekly check-ins |
| Hit targets | Reach 85% of the monthly target in month two and 100% in month three, with the target set before the month starts |
Check each goal against four questions: Is it about their work, not their personality? Is it within their control? Has it been possible for others in the role to meet it? Will you both know, from evidence, whether it happened? If any answer is no, rewrite it. Our guide to the employee with a bad attitude shows how to turn a vague complaint into a described behaviour.
A filled-in example
This is invented for illustration; adapt it to your company's form.
Performance improvement plan: Sam Rivera, customer support specialist
Manager: Dana Lee. Start: 10 November. Check-ins: every Monday at 10:00. Reviews: 8 December and 5 January. End: 5 January.The gap. (1) Response time: in September and October, 38% of Sam's tickets had a first reply after the 4-hour target; the team average is 9%. (2) Quality: in a review of 20 tickets on 28 October, 6 gave an incorrect answer on the refund policy.
Goals. (1) By 8 December, at least 85% of tickets get a first reply within 4 hours; by 5 January, at least 90%. (2) In a spot check of 20 tickets each review, no more than 1 incorrect answer.
Support. Sam will shadow Priya for two hours on 12 November on refund cases. Dana will meet Sam for 30 minutes each Monday to review the previous week's tickets. A refund-policy cheat sheet will be shared by 11 November. Sam can raise any blocker in the weekly meeting or earlier.
If goals are not met. Further action may follow, up to and including ending employment. HR has reviewed this plan.
Signatures. Signing shows the plan was received and discussed.
Notice what it does: it names numbers and dates, compares with the team, shows what the manager will do, and says the consequence once, without drama.
The meeting: what to say
Give the plan in person (or on video if the team is remote), in private, with HR present if your policy requires it. Plan for 30 minutes. Send nothing in advance except a meeting invite that does not alarm them: "Let's talk about your performance and a plan to support it."
- Open with the point, calmly. "I want to talk about something serious. Your work has not been meeting the standard in two areas, and I've written a plan to help you get there."
- Say the gaps with the evidence. "In September and October, 38% of your tickets got their first reply after four hours. The team average is 9%. And in the 28 October review, 6 of 20 refund answers were wrong."
- Say what you want. "By 8 December I need to see 85% inside four hours, and no more than one incorrect answer in 20."
- Say what you will do. "I'll meet with you every Monday, you'll shadow Priya, and I'll share the cheat sheet by tomorrow."
- Be straight about the stakes. "If we don't get there by 5 January, we'll have to consider other steps, up to ending your employment. I'd like us to get there."
- Stop and listen. "What's your view? Is anything getting in your way that I don't know about?" Then let them talk. Write down what they say.
- Close with next steps. "Take the plan home. We'll meet on Monday. If you think a goal is unreasonable, tell me by then and we'll talk about it."
Expect shock, anger, tears or silence. Stay level, don't argue each example, and don't promise outcomes ("you'll be fine") or threaten. If they raise a health issue, discrimination, harassment or a complaint about someone, pause and take it to HR the same day; it changes what you can do.
Running the check-ins
The plan is only as good as the weeks that follow. A weekly 30-minute meeting works for most roles.
- Same time every week, in the calendar before the first meeting.
- Review evidence, not impressions. Look at the numbers or samples together. "This week 80% were inside four hours; last week it was 62%."
- Say what improved first, and be specific. Recognise real progress; people need to know it counts.
- Ask what is in the way, and remove it when you can. If you promised support, give it, and write that down too.
- Write a short note after each meeting: date, what you discussed, progress, any change to the plan, and next steps. Send it to the employee and keep a copy for HR.
- Don't change goals quietly. If you change a target, write the change and why.
Treat the person as you would anyone you want to succeed. If you stop giving them real work or start avoiding them, you are deciding the outcome in advance.
How a PIP ends
| Outcome | What you do |
|---|---|
| Goals met | Tell them in person and in writing that the plan is closed. Keep the weekly check-ins going for a while, then move back to normal one-to-ones. Keep noticing: sustaining it matters |
| Real progress but not there | If your policy allows, extend by a set time with new dates. Say why. Don't extend more than once |
| Not met | Review the evidence with HR before you decide. Then hold the meeting directly: say the result, the decision and the next steps, and treat them with respect |
| The employee leaves | Some choose to resign. Speak with HR about how to handle references, final pay and handover |
For a dismissal after a failed plan, see how to fire an employee nicely, with what to say.
When a PIP is the wrong tool
- One narrow issue. A single, fixable problem, such as a missed process step, is usually better handled with clear feedback and a follow-up date.
- A new hire still learning. Extend onboarding and set a clear ramp instead.
- Serious misconduct. Harassment, theft, violence or safety breaches are handled by HR's disciplinary process, not by a plan designed to coach.
- When the problem is a bad fit. A move to another role, with honest discussion, may help both sides.
Mistakes to avoid
- A surprise. The PIP is the first time they hear it is serious.
- Vague gaps and goals. "Attitude", "engagement" and "ownership" cannot be measured.
- A plan with no support. If you promise nothing, it reads as a countdown.
- Unrealistic targets. Set goals others in the role actually meet.
- Skipping HR. The wrong wording or process can create risk for you and the company.
- Talking about it with the team. Keep it confidential, on a need-to-know basis.
- Deciding the outcome in advance. If so, don't call it a plan to improve.
Questions about performance improvement plans
How long should a performance improvement plan be?
The plan itself should be two or three pages. Its time frame depends on the role and company policy; 30, 60 and 90 days are common, with check-ins every week or two.
What should I include in a PIP?
Basics, the specific gaps with examples, measurable goals, the support you will give, the timeline and review dates, the consequence if the goals are not met, and signatures confirming receipt.
Can an employee refuse to sign a PIP?
They can decline. Note that you delivered it, that they received a copy and the date, and have a witness or HR record it. Signing usually means "received", not "agreed".
Does a PIP mean the employee will be fired?
Not always. Some employees meet the goals and stay. But many employees see it as a warning, so be honest about the stakes and use one only when you want the person to succeed.
Do I need HR involved?
In most companies, yes. HR should review the plan and the wording, and tell you what applies where you work. If you have no HR team, take advice from an employment lawyer or your regional labour department's guidance.
What do I do if the employee improves for a few weeks and then slips?
Address it in the next check-in with the specific evidence, and ask what changed. Follow the plan's timeline and consequences as written, with HR's advice.
Sources
- PerformYard, how to write a performance improvement plan: performyard.com
- Paycor, how to write a performance improvement plan: paycor.com
- Entomo, how to write a performance improvement plan: entomo.co
- For legal questions, your HR team or an employment lawyer; in the US, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission: eeoc.gov
Next: take the free leadership style quiz, or browse all our guides for new managers.
Hard talks go better with words ready.
- A 10-minute lesson a day for 30 days, in the order your quiz answers set
- One ready script a day: the words to open, the pause, the next step
- $39.99 a year or $9.99 a month · cancel in one tap · a receipt your employer can expense