Employee performance review template you can copy and fill in
An employee performance review template needs six parts: the role and period, results against goals, how the work was done, strengths, areas to improve, and goals for the next period. Copy the template below, fill each box from notes you kept during the year, and use the filled-in example and rating scale to keep it fair. It is plain text, so it pastes into Word, Google Docs or your HR tool.
Free · one email
Today's script for the talk you're putting off.
The words to open, the pause and the next step, from a 10-minute lesson. Day 1 is free; plans are $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year after.
Get today's script freeThe employee performance review template (copy this)
Paste this into your document. Each line in brackets is a prompt to replace. The notes under the template say what to write.
Employee: [name] · Role: [title] · Manager: [you]
Review period: [start date] to [end date]
1. Goals and results. For each goal set at the start of the period: the goal, what happened, with numbers where you have them, and a rating.
2. How the work was done. Quality, reliability, teamwork, communication. Two or three examples, each with a date or a project.
3. Strengths. The two or three things they do best, and the effect on the team.
4. Areas to improve. One to three behaviours, each with a specific example and what better looks like.
5. Goals for the next period. Three to five goals, each checkable, with a date.
6. Support and development. What the employee needs from you, and one skill to build.
7. Employee comments. [their words]
Overall rating: [one level from the scale below] · Signed: [manager] [employee] [date]
That is one page. Resist adding twenty more rating boxes: the more boxes, the less each one means. If your company has a mandatory form, use it and treat this template as your note-taking version before you fill it in.
What to write in each section
Goals and results
List the goals from the last review or from the start of the year. If there were none, use the main duties of the role and say so. For each, write what actually happened: "Closed 42 support tickets a week against a target of 40", not "met expectations". Where there is no number, write what changed: "The new onboarding checklist is used by every new hire."
How the work was done
This section is where bias creeps in. Use observed examples: a meeting where they handled a conflict, a handoff that was late, a customer who wrote in to say thank you. If you have no example for a statement, remove the statement.
Strengths
Name them and link them to a result. "Clear writer: her project updates meant I rarely had to ask for status" is useful. "Great team player" is not. Our guide to giving positive feedback has a three-part sentence you can reuse here.
Areas to improve
Keep it to one to three. For each: what you saw, the effect, what you want instead. "In three of the last five sprint demos the slides were sent after the meeting began. I would like them sent by noon the day before so people can read them" works. "Needs to be more organised" does not.
Goals for next period
Write each so that a stranger could check it on the date. "Reduce average response time from 6 hours to 4 by 30 June" can be checked. "Improve responsiveness" cannot. Our guide to setting expectations shows how to turn vague goals into checkable ones.
A filled-in example
This is an example for a fictional customer support agent. Copy the level of detail, not the content.
Employee: Sam Rivera · Role: Support agent · Period: Jan to Jun
1. Goals and results. Goal: resolve 40 tickets a week. Result: average 43, with a dip to 31 in the week of the system migration. Rating: Meets. Goal: customer satisfaction at 90%. Result: 93%. Rating: Exceeds.
2. How the work was done. Sam wrote the migration FAQ the team still uses. Twice in April a ticket was handed over with no notes; the second agent had to ask the customer to repeat the problem.
3. Strengths. Clear, calm replies to upset customers (two escalations were closed after Sam's reply). Documents what he learns.
4. Areas to improve. Handover notes. Better looks like: every transferred ticket has the problem, what was tried and the next step, in three lines.
5. Goals for next period. Handover template used on 100% of transferred tickets by 31 July. Train one new hire on refunds by 30 September.
6. Support and development. Shadow a senior agent on billing calls twice a month.
Overall: Meets expectations, with strengths in customer replies.
Rating scales: pick one and define it
A rating scale without definitions is a mood. Choose three, four or five levels, and write what each means before you rate anyone. Use the same wording for everyone on the team.
| Level | What it means |
|---|---|
| Exceeds | Regularly did more than the role asks, and others learned from it |
| Meets | Did what the role asks, reliably, to the standard |
| Partly meets | Met some goals and missed others; a plan to close the gap is agreed |
| Does not meet | Missed most goals after clear expectations; a formal plan is needed |
Four levels removes the "safe middle" choice, but follow your company's scale if it has one. If an employee lands in the last level, you should not be surprised in the review: they should have heard it in feedback before. If it is new to them, you have a process problem to fix first. Read our guide to a performance improvement plan for the next step.
A self-review form to send first
Ask the employee to fill in a short self-review a week before the meeting. It shows how they see the year and gives you examples you missed. Send these five questions.
- What are you proudest of this period, and why?
- Which goals did you meet, and which did you miss? What got in the way?
- What do you want to do more of, and less of?
- What do you need from me or the team to do your job better?
- Where do you want to be in a year, and what would help you get there?
Read their answers before you finalise yours. If their view is very different from yours, do not change your rating to avoid the argument; instead, plan to ask for their examples in the meeting. If you are writing your own self-review as a manager, our guide to manager self-evaluation examples has sample answers.
Prep checklist: one hour before you write
- Open the last review and the goals you set. Look for the follow-up you promised.
- Scan your notes from one-to-ones, emails and project files for the whole period, not just the last month.
- Write down three examples for strengths and one or two for improvement.
- Check each statement: could you point to something the employee did?
- Ask yourself what you could have done differently to help them.
- Remove words about personality ("lazy", "difficult") and replace them with behaviour.
The biggest problem in most reviews is recency: the last four weeks outweigh the previous forty-eight. A one-line note after each one-to-one fixes this, and our one-on-one meeting template has a place for it.
Running the review meeting
- Open with the purpose (two minutes): "We will look at the last six months, then plan the next six."
- Ask for their view first. Use their self-review.
- Go through results, then strengths, then improvements. Give one example for each point.
- Stop and listen. Ask "What would you add or change?"
- Agree the next goals together. Write them down in the meeting.
- Close with support: what you will do, by when.
Give the written review after the meeting, not before it, unless your company requires otherwise. The talk is the main event; the form is the record.
Mistakes that make a template useless
- Filling it in at the last minute from memory of the last month
- Comparing people to each other instead of to the role
- Surprises: raising a problem for the first time in the review
- Vague words: "good attitude", "strong performer"
- Too many goals: ten goals means none gets done
- No follow-up: goals written and never discussed again until the next review
Questions about performance review templates
What should be included in an employee performance review template?
The role and period, results against goals, how the work was done, strengths, areas to improve, next goals, development support, an employee comment box and an overall rating.
How long should a performance review be?
One to two pages for most roles. Longer forms get filled in with filler. The meeting matters more than the form.
Should I use a rating scale?
If your company requires one, yes. If not, a short written summary with clear examples can work better. Whichever you choose, define each level.
How often should I do performance reviews?
Many companies run them once or twice a year. Regular one-to-ones and small feedback talks in between keep the review from being a surprise.
Is there a free template for Word or Google Docs?
The text template above pastes into either. Put it in a table if you want boxes.
What do I do if I disagree with the employee's self-review?
Share your examples calmly, ask for theirs and note any difference on the form. Do not change a rating only to end the discussion.
Sources
- Our method for specific, behaviour-based feedback: how to write an employee performance review.
- Situation-behaviour-impact feedback model, Center for Creative Leadership: ccl.org
Next: take the free leadership style quiz, or browse all our guides for new managers.
Training only helps if you use it on Monday.
- A 10-minute lesson a day for 30 days, in the order your quiz answers set
- One ready script a day: the words to open, the pause, the next step
- $39.99 a year or $9.99 a month · cancel in one tap · a receipt your employer can expense