Free script

All guides · Feedback

How to write an employee performance review (with example comments)

Good employee performance review comments say what the person did, what effect it had, and what to do next, in specific words with dated examples. Collect evidence through the year, write each comment as behaviour plus result, rate against the standard rather than against colleagues, and make sure nothing in the review is a surprise. Then use the review meeting to listen and agree three goals.

Free · one email

Today's script for the talk you're putting off.

The words to open, the pause and the next step, from a 10-minute lesson. Day 1 is free; plans are $9.99 a month or $39.99 a year after.

Get today's script free

This guide is for managers writing a review for the first time, often with a form from HR and a deadline close. Below: how to gather evidence, a comment formula, example comments for strong, solid and weak performance, wording to avoid, bias traps, how to rate, how to deliver the review, and a one-hour writing routine. Your company's form and rules come first; this helps you fill it well.

What a performance review is for

A review does three jobs: it tells the person where they stand, it records the reasons for pay, promotion or other decisions, and it points to what they should do next. Most reviews fail at the first, because the feedback is vague or arrives too late. The best review is a summary of conversations you have already had. If something in it surprises the person, the problem is not the review; it is that you waited. Our guide on how to give feedback to an employee shows how to do it all year.

Step 1: Gather evidence before you write

Memory is biased toward what happened recently and what was dramatic. Collect evidence first. Spend 20 to 30 minutes per person on:

Write a quick list per person: three or four things they did well with dates, and one or two things to improve with dates. That list is your raw material.

Step 2: Write each employee performance review comment as behaviour, effect, next step

A comment that helps has three parts:

  1. What they did, specific and observable, with when.
  2. What effect it had on the team, a customer, a result.
  3. What to do next: keep doing it, do more of it, or change it.
VagueSpecific
Great team playerIn March you covered two colleagues' shifts during the flu outbreak, which kept our response times under target. Keep offering that, and next, let's use your help to train new hires.
Needs to communicate betterThree times this year (May, July, September), project updates reached me after the client had asked. Sending a short update every Friday would solve this.
Hard workerYou finished the inventory audit two weeks early and found a $4,000 error in the records. The audit is a model for next year.
Poor attitudeIn team meetings in June and August you spoke over colleagues and dismissed ideas before they finished. Others stopped contributing. I need you to let people finish and ask a question before disagreeing.

The same formula works for the weak and the strong. It also protects you: if a comment is about observed behaviour with a date, it is hard to call it unfair. For more wording, see employee feedback examples.

Reviews are one of the hard talks new managers put off. Get today's script free, then see which conversations your style avoids and get a ready script a day.

Employee performance review comments for strong performance

Name the thing and its effect, so the praise is worth something.

For praise that sticks, see how to give positive feedback to an employee.

Example comments for solid, meets-expectations performance

Most people are here, and it is where managers write the dullest reviews. Say what makes the work reliable, and find one stretch.

Employee performance review comments for work that needs improvement

Be plain, specific and fair. Show the gap, the standard and the support.

If a rating is low, the review must not be the first time they hear it. If it is, say so honestly, and own your part: "I should have raised this earlier." If the rating is bad enough to lead to a plan or dismissal, talk to HR and see how to write a performance improvement plan. Our guide on how to give difficult feedback shows how to say it.

Words and phrases to avoid

AvoidWhyUse instead
"Bossy", "abrasive", "emotional", "aggressive"Loaded words that often show up for some groups more than others, and describe a trait, not a behaviourDescribe what happened: "interrupted three colleagues in the 12 June meeting"
"Not a team player"Means nothing specific"Did not share the client list with Jess, which delayed the pitch"
"Always", "never"Easy to rebut with one counterexample"In 6 of the last 10 weeks"
"Seems", "I feel"Sounds like opinionFacts you saw or measured
"Young", "old", "energetic for their age", comments on health, family plans, accent or appearanceCan be discriminatory and create legal riskLeave them out entirely
"Good", "fine", "okay"No informationThe effect: "Reports were accurate and early, so the board pack went out on time"

Bias traps that distort reviews

A quick check: if the person were someone else on your team, with the same results, would you write the same thing?

How to choose a rating

  1. Know the scale's definitions. Read what each level means in your company's form before choosing one.
  2. Rate against the standard for the role, not against colleagues, and not against your hopes.
  3. Start from evidence, then pick the number. Pick the number after writing comments, not before.
  4. Be able to defend it in one sentence, with two examples.
  5. Look at your set of ratings together. If everyone is the same, check you are not avoiding hard calls.
  6. Check with your own manager or HR if you are unsure about a high or a low one. Calibration meetings exist to catch inconsistency.

Delivering the review

Plan an hour. Give the person the written review shortly before or at the start of the meeting, whichever your company does, and don't make them read in front of you for long.

  1. Open: "The purpose today is to look back at the year, agree where you stand, and plan next year. I want to hear your view too."
  2. Ask first: "How do you feel the year went? What are you most proud of?" Listen.
  3. Go through your review: strengths first, with examples; then areas to improve, with examples and the support you will give.
  4. Give the rating plainly, without hedging or apologising, and explain it in a sentence.
  5. Listen to disagreement. If they disagree, ask for their evidence. Change the review if they're right. If not, explain why you are keeping it, and say how they can add their comments to the record.
  6. Agree three goals for the next period, measurable, and one development step.
  7. End with what happens next: when you will check in, and when the form goes to HR.

If the review is difficult, see difficult conversations with employees. If the person gets defensive, our guide on feedback for a defensive employee helps.

A one-hour routine to write one review

MinutesDo this
0–15Read their goals, last review and your notes. List evidence by month.
15–35Write comments for each area as behaviour, effect, next step.
35–45Choose ratings. Check each against the scale's definitions and your evidence.
45–55Read it as the employee. Would anything surprise them? Cut words that describe a trait.
55–60Write three goals for next period and a development step.

Do it in one sitting, not scattered across a week; your standards drift between sessions.

Common mistakes

Questions about writing performance reviews

How do I write a good performance review?

Gather evidence across the whole period, write each comment as behaviour, effect and next step, rate against the standard, check for bias, and finish with three clear goals. Say nothing in the review that you haven't said to the person already.

How long should an employee performance review be?

As long as your form needs and no longer. One to two pages of specific comments beat five pages of general ones.

What do I write for an average employee?

Say what makes them reliable, with examples, and give one stretch goal. "Meets expectations" is a fine result; make it specific.

How do I write a negative performance review?

Name the behaviour with dated examples, the standard, the effect, and the support you will give. Avoid labels about character. Involve HR if the review could lead to a plan or dismissal.

What should I do if the employee disagrees?

Listen, ask for their evidence, and change the review if they are right. If you keep it, explain why and tell them how to add their comments to the record, if your company allows.

Can I use AI to write the review?

You can use it to improve wording, but the evidence and judgments must be yours. Follow your company's policy on sharing employee information with outside tools, and read the result as the employee would.

Sources

Next: take the free leadership style quiz, or browse all our guides for new managers.

Reviews are easier when feedback never waits for them.

  • A 10-minute lesson a day for 30 days, in the order your quiz answers set
  • One ready script a day: the words to open, the pause, the next step
  • $39.99 a year or $9.99 a month · cancel in one tap · a receipt your employer can expense
Get today's script free

Or read a sample lesson first

Want a form to fill in? Copy our employee performance review template, with a filled-in example and rating scale.